Comparison · box and pound prices · read Oct 17
ButcherBox vs Good Chop: box prices, price per pound and shipping
ButcherBox’s Essentials costs $169.00 and Good Chop’s Medium costs $149.00, listed on their brand pages on October 19, 2026. ButcherBox includes shipping; Good Chop’s shipping charge is not published.
ButcherBox and Good Chop have no partner program with this site; Good Ranchers does.
- $8.52–15.23/lb ButcherBox
- boxes from $149.00 Good Chop
- free ButcherBox shipping
Side by side
What makes the boxes comparable?
For the same week’s dinners, compare the cuts and quantities you would use, then the box cost and shipping. Change the pounds of meat in the calculator to frame your comparison. A per-pound range and a starting box price use different price bases.
On the brand pages checked October 17–19, 2026, ButcherBox advertised free protein. Good Chop showed $50.00 off each box with its displayed promo. Neither page published the offer’s full terms, so use regular box prices for ongoing budgeting.
Bottom lineCompare regular box costs first, then check shipping and the offer terms before ordering.
| ButcherBox | Good Chop | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $8.52–15.23/lb | boxes from $149.00 |
| Shipping | free | not published |
| New-customer offer | free protein offer | $50 off each box with the promo shown |
ButcherBox prices
What does ButcherBox charge?
ButcherBox listed Essentials at $169.00 and Signature Medium at $179.00 on its pages on October 19, 2026. Signature Medium lets you choose 6 proteins, with up to 21 pounds in the box.
ButcherBox says shipping is free on every box, so there is no shipping charge to add to these listed prices. No ZIP code was entered for this check, and sales tax is excluded. The ButcherBox cost breakdown covers the listed box options.
Bottom lineEssentials has the lower listed entry price; Signature Medium lists protein choices and a maximum box weight.
| Item | Price | Where | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signature box, Medium (6 proteins, up to 21 lbs) | $179.00 | page | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Signature box, Large (9 proteins, up to 31 lbs) | $249.00 | page | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Signature box, Extra-Large (12 proteins, up to 42 lbs) | $319.00 | page | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Essentials box | $169.00 | page | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Per pound, from | $8.52 | home page | Oct 17, 2026 |
| Per pound, up to | $15.23 | home page | Oct 17, 2026 |
Prices as shown on the brand pages; no ZIP code entered; sales tax not included.
Per pound
Can you compare prices per pound?
ButcherBox listed $8.52–$15.23 per pound on its home page on October 17, 2026. The bottom of that range is a starting price, not a promise for every selection.
That same ButcherBox page claimed Good Chop starts at $10.64 per pound. This is ButcherBox’s claim about its rival, not an independently checked Good Chop price. Use Good Chop’s own box prices when setting a budget.
Bottom lineKeep ButcherBox’s own prices separate from the comparison claims it makes about other brands.
Marks are ButcherBox’s claims about rivals, not checked prices.
| ButcherBox | $8.52 to $15.23 |
|---|---|
| Good Chop per ButcherBox | $10.64 |
| Good Ranchers per ButcherBox | $14.53 |
| Omaha Steaks per ButcherBox | $20.52 |
Good Chop prices
What does Good Chop charge?
Good Chop listed its Medium box at $149.00 on its plans page on October 19, 2026. It describes that box as up to 36 portions or 14 pounds. Both quantities are upper limits.
Good Chop’s shipping amount was not published on the pages read, so it is left out of totals rather than treated as free. No ZIP code was entered, and sales tax is excluded. Confirm shipping before comparing the final checkout amount.
Bottom lineGood Chop’s listed box price is only part of the checkout comparison until shipping is known.
| Item | Price | Where | Checked |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medium box (up to 36 portions or 14 lbs) | $149.00 | plans page | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Large box (up to 72 portions or 28 lbs) | $269.00 | plans page | Oct 19, 2026 |
| Extra Large box (up to 108 portions or 42 lbs) | $359.00 | plans page | Oct 19, 2026 |
Prices as shown on the brand pages; no ZIP code entered; sales tax not included.
Shipping and terms
Can you skip or cancel?
ButcherBox says members can change selections until the night before billing. It allows skipping or cancellation anytime, but processed orders will still ship. Make changes before processing if you want to avoid the next box.
Good Chop’s home page, read October 19, 2026, says customers can skip, reschedule or cancel anytime with no commitments. It also lists delivery intervals of 4, 6 or 8 weeks.
Bottom lineBoth allow skips and cancellation; ButcherBox explicitly says processed orders still ship.
ButcherBox: Skip or pause
Members to change selections up until the night before billing
ButcherBox: Cancel
You can skip or cancel anytime and processed orders will still ship
Which fits whom
Which fits your household’s routine?
ButcherBox fits shoppers who want shipping included in the published box cost. Good Chop offers a stated delivery rhythm for households planning several weeks ahead. Neither subscription’s entry box is a small trial purchase.
For selection, ButcherBox’s home page listed 100+ proteins on October 19, 2026. Good Chop’s home page listed 100+ meat and seafood cuts that same day. Compare the cuts you actually use rather than choosing by the headline selection count.
Bottom lineChoose around box size, preferred cuts and delivery timing, with shipping included in the comparison.
- Suits
ButcherBox: Free shipping
On every box, per the brand.
- Suits
ButcherBox: No long commitment
You can skip or cancel anytime and processed orders will still ship
- Not for
ButcherBox: Small trial orders
Boxes start at $169.
- Suits
Good Chop: No long commitment
Customers can skip, reschedule, or cancel anytime with no commitments
- Suits
Good Chop: Delivery rhythm
Deliveries are available every 4, 6, or 8 weeks
- Not for
Good Chop: Small trial orders
Boxes start at $149.
Partner brands
Where to order
Buttons open the brand’s own site in a new tab. Prices are the brand’s, read on the date shown.
- Good RanchersMeat and seafood box · boxes from $179 · shipping freeNew customers: $100 off the first order
Good Ranchers reviewSee Good Ranchers plans Ad - Wild Alaskan CompanyMeat and seafood box · boxes from $169 · shipping freeNew customers: $25 off the first box
Wild Alaskan Company reviewSee Wild Alaskan Company plans Ad - Grassland BeefMeat and seafood box · items $9.26–$297, priced one by one · shipping free in the US over 15 lbsNew customers: up to 25% back (email sign-up)See Grassland Beef plans Ad
- Chicago Steak CompanyMeat and seafood box · items $129.95–$289.95, priced one by one · shipping free over $199Read Oct 19, 2026See Chicago Steak Company plans Ad
About the buttons. Buttons marked “Ad” are affiliate links: if you order, this site may earn a commission at no cost to you. It never changes the order of results — lists on this site are sorted by the week price.
Next
Read next
Quick questions, short answers
Answers use the prices on this page, read Oct 17–19, 2026.
Is Good Chop cheaper than ButcherBox?
Good Chop listed Medium at $149.00, while ButcherBox listed Essentials at $169.00 on their pages on October 19, 2026. Good Chop has the lower listed entry box price, but the boxes differ and its shipping amount is not published.
Does ButcherBox have free shipping?
ButcherBox says shipping is free on every box. Good Chop’s shipping amount was not published on the pages checked.
What meat options does Good Chop offer?
Good Chop’s home page, read October 19, 2026, describes beef options including USDA Prime, Grass-Fed and Wagyu, alongside pork, chicken and seafood. It says its proteins come from farms and fisheries in the U.S.A.
Can you cancel ButcherBox or Good Chop anytime?
Both brands say customers can cancel anytime. ButcherBox says processed orders will still ship; Good Chop also allows skipping and rescheduling, according to its home page read October 19, 2026.
Sources
- 1ButcherBox: Home pagebutcherbox.com · checked Oct 17, 2026
- 2ButcherBox: Subscription Builderbutcherbox.com · checked Oct 19, 2026
- 3ButcherBox: All Gift Boxesbutcherbox.com · checked Oct 19, 2026
- 4Good Chop: Choose your Plangoodchop.com · checked Oct 19, 2026
- 5Good Chop: Home pagegoodchop.com · checked Oct 19, 2026